Apple’s New Clean Up Tool in iOS 18.1 Beta 3: A Comparison with Google and Samsung AI

Introduction to Apple’s Clean Up Tool

With the release of iOS 18.1 beta 3, Apple introduced two major Apple Intelligence features, one of which is the Clean Up tool. This tool functions similarly to Google’s Magic Eraser, allowing users to remove unwanted elements from their photos. However, its current performance raises some concerns.

Current Performance and Issues

While generative AI features are expected to improve over time, the Clean Up tool has shown some significant shortcomings. One notable issue is its inability to accurately detect and fill in facial data when an image is removed from the foreground. This was highlighted in a post by Mukul Sharma on X, where he attempted to remove a Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 5 from his hand. The result was a distorted mess, with his right side appearing melted.

Comparative Analysis

Despite the impressive on-device proofreading and rewriting capabilities of Apple Intelligence, it struggles with filling in missing areas with accurate detail. In contrast, Samsung’s Galaxy AI produces significantly better results, likely due to its longer availability and more refined parameters.

Future Improvements

It is important to note that these generative AI tools are still in beta and will likely see improvements over time. As the technology evolves, we can expect more accurate and refined results. Users running the beta version of iOS 18.1 are encouraged to share their experiences and results.

Conclusion

Apple’s Clean Up tool in iOS 18.1 beta 3 shows promise but currently lags behind similar tools from Google and Samsung. As the technology progresses, we can look forward to more precise and reliable image editing capabilities.